Saturday, December 31, 2011

Thrilled With My Buy - Free Public Education Book Review

By Isaac Simmons


Why continue down this road when the results we have up to this point show that it has not led us closer to where we want to be? This is exactly what Obama has done with his approach to education.

Anyone who cares about public education should read this book. Heck, every voter should read this book. When Reagan began pushing "school choice," it came as really no surprise he was endorsing ideas of the renowned Milton Friedman. Some studies showed there were no major differences between privatized voucher schools and regular public schools. Ms Ravitch does well in the early part of the book to help the reader understand just how important it is that she has come from one side of the improving public schools debate to the other. I'm a public school administrator highly interested in and believe myself to be well read in arena of reform. I don't recall what my GRE scores were or my SAT nor my IQ level. I do remember working so hard for these two teachers.

There is nothing easier to learn how to do than to vastly improve K-12 education and nothing harder to actually achieve. This book is replete with examples of the latter and contains some good advice for the latter.

Her examination is all the more pointed because of her own career. As assistant secretary of education under president GHW Bush, she was at the center of this emerging philosophy and acted as an official proponent during her time in the administration.

The checks and balance system that is the basis of American democratic philosophy ends with philanthropy. What a philanthropist determines with their checkbook is not up for scrutiny.

John Dewey, one of the towering figures of American educational thought, is not found in the index. OK, she hasn't quite written the book I would have liked her to write. As a long-time educator I was happy to see the care that went into her research that supports her conclusions. Her assessment of the situation is authentic, especially when one learns that she was deep into supporting the reforms and deep into being seated around the tables of the conservative foundation "think tanks" helping to "change" our public schools. While this book is her mea culpa, quite frankly Susan Ohanian and the late Gerald Bracey did this work years ago. Diane Ravitch's latest book is a wonderful assessment of today's dilemmas in education. Before we go any further with Race to the Top, please read this book. A broad, liberal arts curriculum is what's truly needed, but apparently it is nowhere to be found; it is too controversial in these contentious times.

All of us that are interested in public education should aspire to that same goal for ourselves. Ravitch's approach to what she perceives as ailing in education is a finely crafted and highly personal one, personal enough that few readers are likely to find themselves in complete agreement with her. Her critics call her on "flip-flopping" but I see her change of viewpoints as a sign of intelligence. She also defends teachers very well and also teacher unions, two scapegoats the government is blaming for failures to educate.

It is astounding how foundations have affected the direction of our public schools in attempt to run our schools as businesses with choice and accountability. She is the voice for change!




About the Author:



No comments:

Post a Comment